My Dad has always been fond of sharing the caveat that “Nobody ever gave away anything worth having for free.”
(Dad is not a writer, store manger, or Mary Kay Consultant.)
Really? Are high price tags an accurate assessment of quality? Is FREE really just another name for junk?
Okay, then, what’s the deal with FREE?
No question, there’s plenty of free crap stuff being offered around these days, but it’s good to remember that when it comes to free, it is definitely not a case of ONSIZE FITS All. For instance, a well intentioned assessment of FREE would be to consider it as something of a birth announcement– “Lookie lookie, see my newborn pride and joy, isn’t she a beauty?”
There are of course certain degrees of free, but in order for FREE to serve it’s intended purpose of “Try it, you’ll like it,” the object in question needs to be compatible with the hype, or at least good enough to keep everyone from whispering that you have an absolutely hideous baby.
The extender of FREE has to keep in mind that they are in fact aiming a spotlight that will show all the seams and dangling threads in their garment. So while you may be offering something for FREE, you as the giver, must wholeheartedly believe it’s actually worth a million bucks. Thus, in order for FREE to translate into true love and future sales where dollars are exchanged and bank accounts padded, this FREE something must ideally translate into being delicious, memorable, or decidedly unforgettable.
For instance, those FREE food samples many of us are so fond of, I ask you, is that friendly food sample server at Trader Joe’s serving up bottom-of-the-freezer-ignored-to-death items that otherwise haven’t sold? Does the store manager think that offering free samples is a genius plan for cleaning out the soy cocktail weenies wrapped in seaweed that nobody is buying? ” (Note, that such reasoning as they apply to our at home food stuffs do not in any way relate to the discussion at hand, and such methods are not necessarily wrong or otherwise discouraged.) Or, is it actually that someone in the Trader Joe’s empire is banking on a hunch that one miniature taste of Asiago or Sundried Tomato Chicken Sausage will lead to true and forever love? (Btw, YES, YES it will!)
At their best, FREE samples allow us to taste the new foodie treats coming on the scene before making the commitment to buy; slather on the coconut oil lotion to see if it really does make us look ten years younger; read an unknown author’s work to determine if their words nest comfortably in our brains. All this without ever having to make a commitment!
And yet, why then, all the hostility and distrust toward some FREE items, eBooks being a prime example. There have been more than a few scathing comments made in regard to free book promotions and ongoing rants about crappy books crowding the market and causing enormous literary jams when crossing the street contrare to traditionally sold books. Is it really true that if something is free there must be something wrong with it? That anything of value warrents a price tag?
I think the answer resides within the actual purpose of FREE. With food it’s about engaging taste-buds, while with personal products, winners are those that deliver visible results (or that smell really really good.). And when it comes to books, well maybe it’s not as convoluted or diabolical as it might appear to some.
First the disclaimer, YES, there are some hideous, ghastly, and retch worthy books turning up in the FREE zone, but lets keep in mind that there are plenty of the same with a price tag on the cover. Consider that an author offering a book for FREE is most often doing so because their name is not Stephen King, thus having their moniker on the spine of a book means diddly-doo to the book buying public, and they might as well be the invisible man peddling face cream. But that’s not even the most important thing, because first and foremost is an author’s passionate faith fingers crossed prayerful hope that once experienced, their books will no longer simply be a love story waiting to happen, but rather a lifetime commitment.
And if it doesn’t? If the sparks fail to ignite and an a reader feels compelled to break-off the engagement and return to taking out other blind dates? No problem! It’s painless and easy to DELETE what doesn’t entice or appeal, because, hey, it was FREE to begin with.
What do you think of FREE? Love, hate, or distrust it?

Your timing, Barbara, is impeccable. I was just about to open my WIP and begin my work day, and you saved me. Temporarily.
Free. Yes, there absolutely is an angle, and as I read your post the same thoughts were unravelling in my mind. Though I did not think of the spotlight, that idea is spot on!
My book is not in eFormat, but I have given copies away on blog posts. I’ve attended author readings and given the known author my book. Why? Because, as you pointed out, my name is not Stephen King.
If no one tries the seaweed-wrapped cocktail weenies, how can they tell their friends? If they don’t tell their friends, how does the word-of-mouth wheel start turning?
There is a cost when I give a copy of my book away for free. The publisher wants their share, even tho I have a discounted rate, I have to pay for the book. Often, shipping is involved. What is free for the receiver is not free for me.
But, if the strategy works, if I shine the spotlight and the reader is dazzled, I have a new fan. I might get a review on Goodreads. Reader may tell her book club, may loan her copy to her sister, her mother, her friend.
And from that one giveaway, more people know my name. And that is, as a certain credit card would say, PRICELESS!
A resounding YES, Sherry! In addition, you bring another aspect to the banquet of Free, which is the sizable consideration of gambling–and not for fun or profit. As a lover of all things Underdog,I gravitate toward the concept of Grassroots-mojo-pumping-word-of-mouth-movements that absolutely have the power to push our little sailboats alongside the yachts out in the harbor of BIG BOOKS. And I’m sincerely and unshakably convinced that all of our little efforts whether they be the result of Free,(even though, as you are so right in saying — one sided Free!) luck, or persistent prayer, are meaningful and necessary.
Very thought-provoking, Barbara, and I agree with Sherry’s comment.
When I judge the value of free, I have always “considered the source.” Some online entrepreneurs are known for giving away valuable content, so when I see their “free” offer, I pay attention. Others bombard me too much with STUFF and I don’t feel so warm and fuzzy about their offer.
The “know/like/trust” thing that everyone talks about is so important.
I agree with you, Elizabeth – I try to consider the source!
Excellent point, Elizabeth! There’s a glut of questionable Freebies that offer little beyond lumpy filler. And worse of all IMHO, are the dive-bombing Freebie-Flingers whose persistent offerings feel more like an assault than a gift. Recommendations from friends and my writerly comrades carry abundant weight when it comes to the unfamiliar. Thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Great post, Barbara – I agree with you that “FREE” runs the gamut from quality to not so quality…free snacks at Trader Joes? Always welcome. Free books? Love em, and have found some great authors that way! Buy one, get one free Snuggies? Maybe not so much…
Thanks for popping over Laird. Har de har, but why have one Snuggie you’ll never use when you can have TWO!
I find myself increasingly confused by some of the *Free Book* hostility I’ve seem in circulation of late. Simple assessment: No $$$ investment. Love it or hate it. Keep it or delete it. One can argue how this affects the author, but it seems like a win-win for the reader. If it doesn’t jibe it’s an easy enough delete. Quite unlike that $24.99 bestseller that blew the months book budget, but left the reader cold.
Totally!
I’m with your dad on this one except when it comes to free books. I’ll never ever refuse a free book and Amazon indie marketing has broken that free means more sales ultimately.
Like Liv I consider what’s free before taking it simply because it’s free.
Great blog post, Barbara
Hey Judy. Yes, I, too, am loving what Amazon is doing for indies, and there’s sincere joy to be had from supporting authors and very often finding wonderful wonderful books as a result.
There was a time when all things FREE were magical — of course I was 9 years old and my father was right there ready to repeat his Wise Owl Dad words when the Free something turned out to be not so great, lol!.
Laird – Buy one, get one free Snuggies? Lol! If that’s happening somewhere, Armageddon has surely started IMHO.
Barbara – Great post and all good points! Free does not equal quality nor does it equal crap. We should reserve judgment based on the product and not whether it is free or costs money.
Sherry – I agree with the importance of word of mouth, especially when it comes to books. Giving away books for free to spark some word of mouth is definitely valuable in the long run.
Thanks for popping over and dropping your wisdom, Tami! So how about we all grab up some Snuggies, gather-up our Freebie book collections, and talk-up our favorite literature. We’ll pretend it’s a business trip and NOT a slumber party. And if by chance you happened to stop over at Laird’s blog today, you’ll know precisely who it is that will be making the popcorn
Good post. I love your hyphenated word: “Trader Joe’s serving up bottom-of-the-freezer-ignored-to-death items”
Sometimes the free things are ready to be out-dated items. But I love free Kindle e-books. I have gotten to read some terrific new writers. Then as a new fan, I look for their next book. I love reading books written by my Twitter and Wana friends. Heck, I even buy them!
Thank you, Janice. Tee hee, I suspect that T.Joe would not be amused :-O
I absolutely agree with the joy of discovering new writers in the midst of Kindle eBook hopping.
And yes, oh yes, but isn’t it so fabulous finding that so many WANA’s are authoring such wonderful, diverse, and exciting projects?!. I haven’t stopped being amazed by the talents in our little village and I know I’ve only just grazed the surface.
Free always works, but sometimes there is a hidden price.
I just won a free novel before it hits the stores. Problem is, I need to finish it and review it within two weeks (Need to review on the release date)
No pressure.
I just hope I like it. I don’t like to review anything I don’t like, for the sake of the author.